Best cheap car insurance in Tyler

Insurance costs for cars in Tyler, Texas can vary greatly. It pays to research the prices of insurance when they are so varied. Tyler’s average annual minimum auto liability is $547, and the average annual full coverage premium is $1,769 The financial risk to the rest is increased by the fact that approximately 14% Texas drivers are not insured. Uninsured drivers can cause serious injuries to others. Over 14 million were paid in private insurance claims throughout Texas in 2019.

Companies were grouped according to market share and average rates in order to find cheap car insurance in Tyler. The preference was given to those with a higher market share and lower average insurance rates. J.D. next compared the top of these. J.D. next compared the best of these scores with AM Best score for financial strength, power score and discounts. The final five were made up of those who presented well on each of these scores.

Tyler’s best car insurance companies

We compared the premiums of auto insurances available in the region and found the ones with the highest J.D. We also rated their Power ratings. Next, they were evaluated on their AM Best score and any available discounts. Cost and J.D. The most important factors were Power rating and J.D., followed by discounts and AM Best scores.

Insurance CompanyJ.D. J.D.Average Annual Premium for Minimum InsuranceAverage annual premium for full coverage
USAA878 / 1000$406$1,332
Geico846 / 1000$405$1,246
Allstate832 / 1000$583$1,673
State Farm844 / 1000$539$1,420
Nationwide820 / 1000$496$1,306


USAA is a well-respected auto insurance company. Take a look at their J.D. Power score for customer satisfaction. It is however disqualified from the rankings due to its eligibility criteria. USAA insurance is available only to military personnel, veterans, and their immediate families. Tyler has one of the lowest average car insurance rates. While this company does not have the lowest rates for full coverage coverage, the minimum coverage rates are some of the most affordable in the area. USAA is definitely worth looking into if you are eligible.


Geico has some of the most affordable insurance, while still maintaining high ratings. They score extremely well on the J.D. The Power report. Geico offers more discounts than its competitors, and has the lowest average premium. Geico has the lowest average rate on Tyler’s minimum and full coverage, out of all five. Geico is a top contender for cheap car insurance in Tyler thanks to its low costs, great discounts, and outstanding ratings.


Allstate is the most established and largest auto insurance company in America. It continues to be a top-ranked company on the J.D. The company has continued to rank well on the J.D. Power report for several years. The average rates paid by the company for full and minimum coverage are significantly lower than the Texas average. They offer great discounts and reward programs. Allstate is Tyler’s most affordable car insurance company. They have high ratings and offer quality products with convenient savings.

State Farm

State Farm is the largest American auto insurance company. It was fifth in the Texas region for 2020 J.D. The Power report. This company also offers a telemetric-based discounts program, just like its competitors. The Drive Safe and Save program gathers real-time data from your vehicle and offers discounts based on how safe it is being driven. State Farm charges a high rate for this list but offers discounts and high ratings to offset it.

All over the country

Nationwide is a long-standing member of the top ten in the J.D Power report. Nationwide also offers extensive coverage and discounts options that offer a balance of affordability and quality. Nationwide offers the lowest average full coverage rates among our top five. Nationwide offers a usage-based, telematics app called SmartRide that may offer significant discounts in line with industry trends. As with other safe driver programs for auto insurance, the more secure the driver, the greater the discount.

Tyler has the lowest car insurance

The average cost of car insurance in the United States for basic coverage is $565 and $1,674 respectively. Texas drivers spend an average of $524 per year and $1,823, respectively. The annual average price of Tyler auto insurance is $547 for minimum coverage and $1,769 full coverage. Texas auto insurance is more expensive than other states. There are still affordable auto insurance options available in Tyler, Texas.

Geico is the most affordable auto insurance in Tyler, Texas, compared to the more well-known and popular insurers. Both USAA and Geico consistently score well on the J.D. Power report. AM Best awarded Geico an A++ rating to demonstrate financial strength. USAA also received the same. Geico offers a variety of discount options and rates that are lower than the average local rate. Both companies are a good fit for the lowest car insurance in Tyler.

Insurance CompanyAverage Annual Premium for Minimum InsuranceAverage annual premium for full coverage
All over the country$496$1,306
State Farm$539$1,420

Tyler insurance requirements

Texas auto law applies in Tyler. This includes the mandatory minimum insurance laws. Minimum liability coverage is the minimum coverage required for all drivers. This is the minimum amount of coverage a Texas driver can legally have. However, many drivers choose to buy more coverage.

Minimal liability covers only damages you cause to other people and their property. It does not cover you or yours. Let’s say a driver who has only minimal liability is at fault in a car accident. Their insurance will cover the costs of the other driver (up to a certain limit), but they will not pay the driver at fault for their own expenses. Some people buy more coverage.

Auto liability insurance in Tyler, Texas

  • Bodily Injury: $30,000 per Person and $60,000 per Accident
  • Property damage: $25,000 per accident

Tyler offers car insurance discounts

  • Policy for multi-cars
  • Multi-policy
  • Good driving
  • Good student
  • Safety equipment for vehicles

There are many discounts in Tyler, Texas, depending on which insurance provider you choose. These are some of the most common discounts in the region. These can all make a big difference in your premiums. Multi-car policies and multipolicy discounts are two of the best ways to save money. These discounts can save you money if you have more than one insurance policy with the same company. They may charge less for multiple cars than they would for one. Multiple policies are the same. You may get a discount if you take out both an auto and homeowners policy from the same provider.

Questions frequently asked

Which is the best auto insurance company?

While the answer to this question will vary from one customer to another, the best auto insurance company should be able meet your coverage requirements without breaking your budget. Consider how much coverage you require, what you can afford and how risky driving is. Take a look at the Bankrate article about the Best Car Insurance Companies in 2021.

What is the cost of car insurance in Tyler?

Car insurance in Tyler is on average $547 for minimum coverage and $1769 for complete coverage. You should shop around for quotes on car insurance in Tyler, Texas. You can often find lower rates by shopping around. This can help you save even more on your premiums.

What amount of car insurance do you need in Tyler

Texas law requires all drivers to have minimum liability auto insurance. This is $30,000 bodily injury liability for each person and $60,000 per accident in Tyler, Texas. Additional $25,000 per accident property damage liability.

Why pay more for auto insurance than is necessary?

Because minimum liability does not cover other bills, some people choose to buy more coverage. If a driver is at fault, their liability insurance will cover the injuries and damages they cause but not the ones they receive. Some people also add additional policies or full coverage to their auto insurance.