Geico vs. Allstate: Car insurance comparison

Geico, and Allstate have been two of the most popular and largest auto insurance companies in the country. Geico was established in 1936 during the Great Depression, but it grew steadily. Warren Buffet purchased Geico in 1996 and it is now a Berkshire Hathaway Group subsidiary. With 13.5% market share in 2020, it is the second-largest car insurance company in America. Geico maintains its competitive edge with providing a wide range of discounts to suit every need.

Allstate was established in 1931. Allstate is known for their innovation. In 1936, they introduced a new approach to auto insurance by creating policies that were based on driver age and vehicle type. Many others followed their lead. With a 9.11% market share, Allstate is today the fourth-largest private auto insurance company in the United States. Allstate offers many great discounts.

Both providers have a history and are well-known, but it can be difficult to choose between Allstate and Geico if you don’t know enough.

Geico vs. Allstate: Car insurance rates comparison

Geico and Allstate are both leaders in the U.S. auto insurance market with strong financial ratings from AM Best. The J.D. also rates each company highly. Power score for customer satisfaction. Geico’s average annual premiums for Allstate are lower than Allstate’s. However, Allstate offers many policy options and discounts that can help drivers get affordable coverage.

Rates based on credit score

Both companies take into account credit scores when setting premiums. Allstate, however, will charge more for those with poor credit. Insurers consider applicants with poor credit ratings to be more likely to fail to pay premiums on time and to drive recklessly. Some states, including California, Hawaii and Maryland, prohibit or limit the use of credit scores to write auto insurance.

Rates based on age

Both Allstate and Geico follow common insurance trends when determining premiums. However, Allstate is clearly more aggressive. Allstate’s 18-year-old premium is nearly $2,500 more than Geico’s and much higher than Allstate’s premiums for other ages. After drivers turn 30, both companies see their premiums drop.

Driving record rates

Driver records can be strong indicators that a driver is at higher risk. Most insurers will charge higher premiums if there are more traffic violations. Allstate’s annual premiums are affected more by DUI convictions than Geico’s, but both premiums increase with poor driving records.

Geico vs Allstate: discounts

Geico offers large discounts in many niches such as equipment enhancements, driver education, driver history, driver loyalty, and driver affiliations. Allstate offers similar discounts, and with other carriers, a disappearing-deductible . This reduces an insurance policy deductible by a specific amount every year that the driver isn’t involved in an accident.

Geico discounts

  • Equipment discounts: These are available to eligible policyholders following the installation of safety equipment, such as anti-lock brakes and anti-theft devices.
  • Discount of up to five years for good drivers who have not been in an accident: This discount is based on a clean driving record.
  • Discounts for driver affiliation: Drivers who are affiliated with the military, federal employees and those with affiliations with more than 500 companies can get discounts.

Allstate discounts

  • Administrative efficiency discounts: These discounts are usually available when you bundle two or more Allstate policies.
  • Smart student discounts are available to unmarried drivers younger than 25 who complete the Allstate TeenSMART(r), driver education program, and attend school less than 100 miles from the garage where their car is stored.
  • Safety and protection equipment: Anti-lock brakes and anti-theft devices often come with discounts

Geico vs Allstate – Online and Mobile Experience Comparison

Geico’s website is one of the most user-friendly in the industry. Geico’s insurance Virtual Assistant provides a powerful self-improvement resource for researching and assistance with claims and applications. Allstate offers online capabilities and agent services to improve customer experience. The company provides a great tutorial about how to prepare for obtaining quotes.

Both companies offer mobile apps that are useful:

Questions frequently asked

Which insurance policy is best for your car?

There are many great car insurance policies and companies. You may not need the best insurance, but it might be the right one for you. To find the best policy for you, search online the top car insurance companies.

Which car insurance company offers the best discounts?

There are discounts for every car insurance company. The companies reviewed here offer a wide range of discounts. To learn more about discounts offered by different companies and determine which discounts are available, you can search for them online .

How do I find the best car insurance for my budget?

Comparison shopping is the best way to compare prices and find coverage that meets your needs. Get quotes from several companies that are affordable. This will help you find the best affordable policy.