What Are the Best Insurance Companies?

Selecting the ideal insurance company depends upon your unique needs and expectations. When searching, look for an insurer with both strong financial strength ratings from AM Best and excellent customer satisfaction reviews.

GEICO provides great rates and discounts for young drivers, such as bundling, safe driving and multi-vehicle policies. Furthermore, they also provide add-on coverages like roadside assistance and rental car reimbursement.


GEICO is one of the nation’s premier auto insurers and offers an array of coverage options at highly competitive rates. Their user-friendly online application makes acquiring policies simple; there’s even an optional mobile app and 24/7 customer service to assist drivers if any questions arise. In fact, Berkshire Hathaway owns and runs this GEICO subsidiary – its diverse portfolio comprises investments across healthcare, financial services, energy infrastructure and infrastructure investments.

It has long been recognized for offering affordable auto insurance rates, especially to new teen drivers and families with multiple vehicles. Their basic auto policy provides collision and comprehensive coverage as well as additional extras such as roadside assistance and rental reimbursement coverage, roadside assistance and rental reimbursement coverage, military membership discounts and low mileage discounts that help bring costs down for policies such as anti-theft/passive restraint safety features such as anti-theft/passive restraint safety features for anti-theft/passive restraint safety features and those driving less often or who belong to professional organizations – and their accident forgiveness add-on can keep rates from increasing after your first at-fault collision.

Though Geico is widely respected for providing outstanding customer service, some customers have experienced long wait times to reach an agent. Their claims process, however, is generally considered efficient and reliable and has an excellent track record for paying out claims quickly and without issue.

Geico car insurance is an ideal choice for tech-savvy customers who enjoy purchasing and managing their policy online or over the phone, and its rates are below the national average, making it an attractive proposition if looking to bundle home and life policies together in order to save money. Unfortunately, customer satisfaction ratings with Geico can sometimes fall below par in some regions.


USAA car insurance is only open to active military and their family members; however, it remains one of the top car insurers for those eligible. Their rates are significantly below average while EverQuote’s survey of auto insurers scores them well for customer service and mobile app usage. USAA also features its highly-rated mobile app for viewing ID cards, accessing policy details, requesting roadside assistance or filing claims as well as offering its SafePilot telematics program which tracks driving behaviors such as hard braking that could save up to 30%!

USAA provides an array of add-on services, such as accident forgiveness, roadside assistance and gap insurance (which covers any difference between what you owe on your car and its actual value if totaled or stolen). Their auto insurance rates are among the lowest in the industry while customer satisfaction ratings remain consistently high – USAA scored 711 out of 1000 points in J.D. Power’s 2024 auto insurance survey which is well above industry norms.

GEICO stands out among insurance providers for families with young drivers due to its competitive rate discounts and excellent customer service, available across most states. Furthermore, its user-friendly website contains an array of jargon-free resources designed to assist customers understand their coverage. In terms of auto insurance policies specifically, GEICO stands out as being an outstanding choice when working online through an agent.

MoneyGeek conducted research to analyze the best car insurers in each state. Since insurance is regulated at a state level, MoneyGeek performed analysis on which insurer was the top performer across each. GEICO led in 23 states and Washington D.C. while USAA came second place two states over and third place one state over. State Farm and Erie regional insurers both received top honors among other providers across 10 states respectively.


Progressive is well known as one of the industry’s leading insurance providers for their innovative strategies such as drive-in claims service and pay-as-you-drive user-based auto policies. Progressive is well known for offering a diverse selection of insurance policies that go far beyond cars; their services cover classic vehicles, boats and even motorcycles! Furthermore, Progressive was among the first companies to launch an informative website. Progressive is currently the second-largest car insurer in the US with just under 14% market share, offering fair rates to drivers with past speeding tickets or accidents resulting in collisions. Their Snapshot telematics program offers customers an incentive for driving responsibly by offering reduced premiums as a reward.

Progressive offers home and auto coverage in all 50 states, from homeowners policies that protect personal belongings from fire and most acts of nature to auto policies with customizable coverage levels and discounts such as good student, teen driver and low mileage driver discounts. They even provide special rewards for low mileage drivers.

Progressive has earned an A rating from AM Best and boasts outstanding financial strength, offering 24/7 customer service as well as being extremely active on social media and boasting a mobile app to easily compare quotes and manage accounts. Furthermore, Progressive provides its policyholders with numerous benefits, such as deductible savings bank and an online tool to aid claim management; in addition they have various discount options including name your price feature and e-documents for increased convenience.


Travelers is one of the oldest and best-known insurance providers in the country, providing home, auto, boat and yacht coverage as well as travel and umbrella policies for homeowners, renters and landlords. Additionally, Travelers offers policy add-ons such as landlord and pet coverage along with discounts available both for auto and home policies as well as accident forgiveness coverage (available with some policies), new car replacement coverage (some policies only) as well as rideshare options which may be available in certain states.

WalletHub editors rated Nationwide 4.2 stars out of 5, with some complaints regarding unexpected claim denials and response times being slower than anticipated. Furthermore, their rates tend to be higher than other insurers and they received below-average scores on J.D. Power surveys for claims satisfaction and digital experience surveys.

Travelers insurance rates may be more expensive, but their services provide many advantages. One such benefit is their Common Loss Bundling option which reduces deductibles when both home and car are damaged in an incident at once. Furthermore, Travelers offers add-ons like roadside assistance, pet coverage and rental reimbursement as well as their IntelliDrive 90 Day Driver Tracking program that could save up to 30% off car premiums.

Customers looking for robust policy options and want a convenient way to manage multiple policies should consider this company, which has earned high financial strength ratings from A.M. Best Co., Fitch Ratings and Moody’s Investors Service.


There are dozens of car insurance companies with great customer service ratings, but only some deserve your consideration. The top providers will offer benefits like competitive rates and discounts; comprehensive accident coverage; as well as discounts to help save you money and protect against financial loss from accidents. With their benefits come savings that help both protect you financially as well as safeguard your vehicle against damage.

State Farm, GEICO, Allstate, Progressive and Travelers are some of the premier auto insurers in the US. Each scored highly in Policygenius’ 2022 survey and boasted high financial strength scores from AM Best. Furthermore, each offers different coverage options, such as new car replacement and accident forgiveness coverage options; several even provide rideshare driver coverage – offering peace of mind when driving as part of their job duties.

Farmers is another top pick when it comes to car insurance. Their customer satisfaction ratings surpass competitors and offer a comprehensive array of coverages including OEM coverage, new car replacement coverages, decreasing deductibles and accident forgiveness. Furthermore, Farmers has an outstanding record in handling claims while offering cost-effective premiums.

Nationwide provides reliable car insurance at an attractive rate, offering coverages such as new car replacement and rideshare protection tailored specifically to each driver’s needs. Rates are competitive but may increase if teen drivers or DUI arrests come into the picture.

When searching for the ideal car insurance company, it is wise to obtain multiple quotes from different providers. Different providers use various rating factors when calculating rates; it could be that one offers lower premiums than another. Also take advantage of any discounts available such as being a safe driver or bundling your home and auto policies together.