Who Has the Best Home Insurance?

Consumers looking for home insurance should always shop around to find the most competitive rates. When doing their research, consumers can utilize JD Power customer satisfaction ratings and the National Association of Insurance Commissioners complaint database to make an informed decision.

Amica Mutual boasts an exceptional customer satisfaction rating and offers various discounts. Additionally, they have an expansive contractor network as well as Guaranteed Replacement Cost coverage.


Amica Home Insurance Company offers standard home coverage as well as special policies like the Platinum Choice policy to expand your options of protection. They also provide various discounts such as e-discounts, multi-policy discounts and loyalty discounts; in addition, Amica also has home warranty options and provides access to an vetted contractor directory database.

Amica is an attractive option for homeowners due to its impressive industry ratings and A+ rating from AM Best. Furthermore, Amica is financially sound with a lower-than-average number of complaints filed to state insurance departments, excellent customer service and high marks in J.D. Power U.S. Homeowners Insurance Study scores; plus it features an online claim center.

Amica home insurance provides multiple quotes quickly and lets customers customize a policy quickly. Their website features a calculator to estimate how much it might cost to insure your home, along with any specific coverages or add-ons you need. Customers can even start the purchasing process on the site itself; once complete they must contact an agent.

Amica provides an impressive array of discounts, such as e-discounts and paperless statements as well as the option of prepaying premiums in advance. They even provide multi-line discounts which could save up to 30% when combined with auto, condo, renters or life coverage.

Amica goes above and beyond simply offering discounts with its various special features that set it apart from other insurers. For instance, Amica covers the costs associated with temporary living arrangements if your home becomes uninhabitable due to a covered event; they will also reimburse for replacement roof or water heater replacement if damage occurs to either of those elements in your home.

Amica home insurance costs are slightly above average, but with its discounts and unique coverages it may be worth considering. Furthermore, they boast an impressively low complaint rate, making them an excellent option for homeowners searching for customer satisfaction.


Chubb home insurance policies feature extended replacement cost coverage, home appraisal appraisal and security features as well as upgrades required by building laws or ordinances. Personal Property Replacement Coverage from this company provides a full reimbursement of the value of your possessions regardless of their depreciation. Chubb also provides additional benefits, including tree removal after storms and data recovery from computer viruses – services which are available across most states. Chubb also offers GreenWise coverage, which enables homeowners to upgrade to energy efficient appliances and eco-friendly building materials. Furthermore, its HomeScan program detects leaks, missing insulation or electrical connections before damage occurs.

Chubb is an industry-leading homeowner’s insurer in New York, offering both affordable premiums and exceptional customer satisfaction ratings. MoneyGeek recently named Chubb the number-one home insurance company for New York homeowners based on factors including customer service levels, claims ratings and affordability – it even awarded them with top honors!

Chubb offers more than home and auto insurance policies; in particular, it offers coverages tailored specifically for high-value assets. Loss of use coverage reimburses meals and transportation expenses should your home become uninhabitable while personal liability coverage provides compensation if someone is injured on your property.

At Travelers Insurance Company, they also provide specialty coverages for high-value items like art and jewelry that would normally be excluded from standard policies, but can be purchased as standalone policies. Furthermore, their Masterpiece policy offers premium service for those insuring significant assets with up to $100 million liability coverage; it features an extensive property inventory list as well as wildfire defense services in fire-prone areas and offers cash settlement should you decide not to rebuild after disaster strikes.

Andover Companies

The Andover Companies are an insurance group offering homeowners, condo, renters and umbrella coverage as well as auto, boat and business policies. Their products have been recognized by A.M. Best with an “Excellent” rating; additionally they take pride in providing reliable products through an extensive network of independent agents who stand committed to their customers and service them well.

Homeowners insurance from The Andover Companies is available in most states and offers comprehensive coverage options and competitive pricing, such as guaranteed replacement cost coverage. Their average annual policy with $300K dwelling coverage costs only $1240 annually which is 40% lower than the national average rate. Furthermore, The Andover Companies provides several discounts such as automatic payment discount and paperless statement discount as well as the ability to bundle them together to save an extra 5% by bundling them together with personal umbrella, boat or dwelling fire policies.

Other advantages include being able to transfer an existing homeowners policy onto a new mortgage, having access to home repair assistance programs and insuring your home business with your homeowner’s policy. You could save money on premiums by increasing your deductible amount; it is essential that you understand any associated risks before making this decision.

USAA is an outstanding home insurer with outstanding customer satisfaction ratings and financial strength ratings. One of the few insurers offering Guaranteed Replacement Cost coverage, USAA makes sure to replace damaged belongings rather than receiving their depreciated value as compensation for damage or destruction. Plus, their low cost of ownership makes for effortless ownership experience with superior customer service!

Established in 1828, this insurance provider boasts an illustrious history. Their home insurance is currently offered in Illinois and select Northeastern states and received five stars out of five by NerdWallet after being evaluated on various factors, such as coverage options, customer satisfaction ratings, website transparency ratings, financial strength ratings and complaint data. They also offer auto, life, disability and business policies with property, liability and systems protection endorsements available as options that cover household appliances or equipment that might otherwise become subject to loss or theft.

State Farm

State Farm stands out among home insurers as an affordable choice with excellent financial strength, earning rave reviews from its customers who rated State Farm at 83% as likely to recommend their home insurance to friends and family in our 2024 survey – more than any other insurer ranked! It has strong presence nationwide through local agents that help homeowners understand coverage options and find an ideal policy policy.

State Farm offers several add-on coverages that can help homeowners save money on premiums, such as flood and personal property insurance policies that cover damage from flooding, as well as personal property coverage to cover a homeowner’s belongings in case of covered loss. Furthermore, its home security feature helps safeguard homes against unauthorized entry while monitoring any activity taking place inside.

State Farm policies offer another advantage with its replacement cost coverage, which provides homeowners with the amount it would cost them to rebuild their home if it was completely destroyed by fire, natural disaster or theft. State Farm uses actual cash value rather than depreciated values to calculate contents values; plus their policies offer greater flexibility allowing individuals to increase or decrease deductibles in order to decrease premium costs by several hundred dollars.

However, choosing a higher deductible will increase homeowner responsibilities should they file a claim, so it is wise to carefully consider this factor when choosing a deductible amount. State Farm also mandates its customers notify them within 90 days of any renovation projects which could alter replacement cost calculations of their home.

State Farm goes beyond standard home insurance coverages to offer additional services such as home warranties that provide repair and maintenance for appliances, plumbing and electrical systems. They can even be purchased separately from its regular homeowners policy.

Customer service at this company is also excellent, with relatively few complaints compared to industry average. Representatives are available 24 hours a day to answer queries and assist with claims, with discounts offered when bundling both home and auto policies, installing protective devices like burglar alarms or having impact-resistant roof shingles installed.