Best cheap homeowners insurance in Cleveland

Cleveland is a city with a rich cultural history. 41.6% residents own their homes in the city. The city is plagued by crime and winter weather challenges, so homeowners insurance policies are a must.

A $250K home’s average homeowners insurance rate is $1,165. This is lower than the average of $13,312. Bankrate reviewed cost, customer service, and financial stability to find the best home insurance rates in Cleveland.

Cleveland’s best home insurance company

We compared the average premium rates of Cleveland’s home insurance providers to determine which ones had the lowest. This included rankings and consumer watchdog agencies like J.D. Power & Associates and the available coverage options. These five were the winners.


Auto-Owners’ annual average premium is $865 for $250K coverage. This is $300 lower than the Cleveland average. It ranks near the top of J.D. Power’s Home Insurance Study monitors customer satisfaction.

Auto-Owners is a great option for homeowners with high-value properties. It provides additional coverage for items like boat repair and off-road vehicles and personal property. This gives you more protection than the average policy.

American Family

AmFam provides low rates to Cleveland homeowners. This is well below the city average. It has good ratings from consumer watchdogs and an AM Best rating of “A”, which assesses financial soundness.

American Family offers a few optional coverages, such as equipment breakdown, matching siding protection, sump pump and backup. You can also get discounts such as a loyalty discount or a new home discount.


Allstate’s average rates tend to be low, and the company is well-known for providing professional and reliable customer service. You can also get an optional feature called Claim Rateguard that will ensure your premium does not increase just because you file a case.

Allstate offers a wide range of optional coverages that include identity theft restoration and electronic data recovery. There are discounts available for bundling homeowner and auto insurance. You can also get a discount for having a great payment history. Allstate will reward you with a 20% claim-free bonus if you do not have a home insurance claim.

State Farm

State Farm is not the best in the industry for customer service or low premiums, but it has decent, above-average scores. Its website ranks among the top in the industry. It also features a blog which helps you learn about homeownership and insurance.

Although State Farm offers fewer discounts than other insurers, the ones it does offer may still be a savings. Bundling, home alert systems and impact-resistant roofing products are all examples of discounts.

All over the country

Despite having the highest average price among our top five choices, Nationwide’s average premium cost is still lower than the Cleveland average. It offers standard liability and dwelling coverage. However, Nationwide also has optional coverage endorsements such as identity theft, replacement cost plus (which pays an additional 20% if your home is damaged) and flood insurance.

If you qualify for discounts, your rate could be lower than Nationwide’s average. You may be eligible for discounts for being claim-free, doing roof or home renovations, or living in a gated community.

Cleveland home insurance options

Cleveland does not require homeowners insurance. However, your mortgage lender may require that you have a policy. A basic policy will protect your home, belongings, and other structures as well as liability from a number of perils. This includes fire, wind, and hail damage. These optional riders or endorsements include:

  • Flood insurance: Flood insurance is mandatory if you live in a flood area. It is not covered by regular homeowners policies. If your property is located near water bodies, your insurer might offer policies through the National Flood Insurance Program.
  • Identity theft restoration: Identity theft has become a growing problem. Many insurers offer coverage to pay the legal fees and other costs that may be incurred if your identity is stolen. This protection may be included in your policy’s base or as an additional endorsement.
  • Scheduled personal property: This optional coverage offers a higher level to protect valuable items like jewelry, antiques, and fine art. There may be coverage available for electronic equipment, sports equipment, and musical instruments.

Cleveland Home Insurance Discounts

A homeowner should have the option to use discounts to lower their premiums. Many insurers offer discounts, and many are easy to get.

These are some of the most common offers for Cleveland homeowners.

  • Loyalty discount: If you are a long-term policyholder, there might be a chance to save between 5-10% and 10%.
  • Bundling: Most insurers offer a discount for multiple policies, such as home and car or life and auto.
  • Online policy management: You may be able to save up to 5% if you opt for email delivery of your insurance documents instead of postal mail. Online bill payment can also help you save.
  • Protective devices: Any device that helps protect your home from harm should be eligible for a discount. This includes sprinkler systems, burglar alarms, smoke detectors and other security devices.

Each insurer has a unique discount list. The amount of the discount will vary from one insurer to the next. However, these discounts are most common with national companies like Allstate or State Farm.

Questions frequently asked

Which is the best company for home insurance?

The best insurance company for you is one that provides the most comprehensive coverage at a low price, and offers excellent customer service. There are many great insurance companies writing policies throughout Cleveland. It is best to call multiple agents to get quotes and to work with them to compare.

What is the cost of Cleveland home insurance?

For a property worth $250K, the average cost for home insurance in Cleveland is $1165. Your cost will likely vary. Multiple factors influence the premium price, including where it is located and how old it is, its material and credit rating.

What amount of Cleveland home insurance do you need?

Home insurance is necessary to ensure that your home can be rebuilt in the event of a natural disaster. This is not your home’s actual market value. It is based on the average cost of construction in your area per square foot. Your realtor, or your agent if you’re just buying a home, can help you calculate this amount.